Magic Puzzle Company Series 1 vs Series 2: Which Puzzle Set Should You Buy?

Quick Answer

If you prefer whimsical, colorful scenes with hidden stories, Series 1 offers a delightful mix. If you're drawn to mysterious, nature-inspired art with a touch of melancholy, Series 2 might be your pick. Both series deliver the same high-quality puzzling experience, so your choice really comes down to art style and theme.

Magic Puzzle Company has captivated puzzle enthusiasts with its unique 'mystery puzzles' that include hidden surprises and cohesive art. When deciding between Series 1 and Series 2, you're essentially choosing between two curated sets of three puzzles each, each with its own artistic vibe and storytelling approach. This comparison breaks down the key differences to help you decide which series aligns with your preferences.

Both series are sold as bundles, offering three puzzles for the price of two, which is a great value. But the art and themes differ significantly, so let's dive into what each series brings to the table.

Artistic Styles and Themes

Series 1 is known for its vibrant, playful illustrations. The puzzles in this series—The Happy Isles, The Mystic Maze, and The Sunny City—feature bright colors, fantastical settings, and a sense of adventure. The art is whimsical and inviting, perfect for those who enjoy a cheerful puzzling experience.

Series 2 takes a different turn with a more mysterious and atmospheric tone. The Crystal Caves, for instance, explores an ancient rivalry with a focus on natural processes and nostalgia. The illustrations are often more detailed and moody, appealing to puzzle lovers who appreciate depth and storytelling in art.

• Consider what mood you want during puzzling: cheerful and energetic (Series 1) vs. contemplative and mysterious (Series 2).

Bundle Value and Pricing

Both Series 1 and Series 2 bundles are priced at $37.50, which is a significant saving compared to buying each puzzle individually at $12.50 each (totaling $37.50, but the comparison price suggests a higher value). The bundle effectively gives you three puzzles for the price of two, making it a smart purchase for collectors and newcomers alike.

Each puzzle in the series is also available individually, so you can sample a single puzzle before committing to a full series. However, the bundle offers the best value, especially if you're already drawn to multiple puzzles in the series.

• If you're on a budget, the bundle is the way to go—you get three puzzles for the price of two.

Hidden Surprises and Replayability

Magic Puzzle Company puzzles are famous for their hidden surprises—after completing the puzzle, you discover extra pieces that form a secret image. Both Series 1 and Series 2 deliver this delightful twist, adding replay value and a sense of discovery.

The hidden surprises in each series are designed to complement the theme. Series 1's surprises are likely to be as playful as its art, while Series 2's might tie into the mysterious narratives. This makes each puzzle a unique experience, regardless of which series you choose.

• Both series offer the signature hidden surprise, so the decision isn't about features but about which art style resonates more with you.

Trade-offs to Consider

• Art Style: Series 1 is bright and playful; Series 2 is darker and more mysterious. Choose based on your preferred aesthetic.
• Theme Variety: Series 1 includes islands, mazes, and cities; Series 2 features caves and other natural settings. Think about which settings you find more intriguing.
• Value: Both bundles are priced the same, offering three puzzles for the price of two. Value is equal, so the decision is purely about preference.

Series Highlights

• The Crystal Caves: Unearth the final outcome of an ancient and bitter rivalry. This puzzle tells a story of conflict and resolution, perfect for those who enjoy narrative-driven art.
• Series 1 Bundle: Includes The Happy Isles, The Mystic Maze, and The Sunny City. This bundle offers a diverse set of whimsical themes, giving you a taste of different adventures in one purchase.

Which Series Fits You?

Best for

• Fans of cheerful, colorful art and lighthearted themes (Series 1)
• Those who enjoy a mix of adventure and whimsy in their puzzling

Not for

• Puzzle enthusiasts who prefer darker, more introspective art (choose Series 2)
• Collectors who want to complete a specific series based on art style consistency

Ultimately, both Magic Puzzle Company Series 1 and Series 2 offer exceptional quality and value. Your choice should reflect your personal taste in art and storytelling. Whether you start with the vibrant adventures of Series 1 or the mysterious depths of Series 2, you're in for a delightful puzzling experience.